Hi Nancy! I agree, that isn't the one that you thought it was! Your soil could make a difference, but there is no way that it could make that much of a difference! I have no idea which daylily it is, and it may be impossible to find out, but it's always worth trying. It would be helpful if you could provide some stats on the plant. Bloom side and height would be great to know. That could narrow it down more, if someone thinks it is familiar.