Patty - thought I'd share how I deal with this issue - If I lose a label or have a situation like yours where the plant is mislabeled, and I decide its what I "think" it is and I give it a label - I always add a ? after the name on my label so I know that there was some confusion. I think for people who are trying to keep their plants correctly ID'd it keeps surprises to a minimum!! Just my 2 cents!
I have a plant "Georgette?" which I'm 99.9% sure is Georgette but the label was lost and I received some NOIDs around the same time, so it is possible that its a NOID that looks like the real 'Georgette' I will always explain that to anyone I give chicks to so it doesn't fully get labeled as Georgette...maybe I'm overly cautious, but I feel that with the efforts people are making to get plants correct, its the least that I can do!