OldGardener, instead of using this forum to question a photo ID or sending a personal tree-mail, it might be better to question the ID in a comment about the questionable photo.
Just click on the photo in question to enlarge it, then scroll down to "Post a comment about this photo," and express your concerns. That comment will end up in the Plant Photos Forum and the owner of the photo will automatically be alerted to the comment in his or her "Watched threads" messages. The forum is regularly watched by many knowledgeable members who may lend support to your comment. This can be particularly useful if you're questioning an image whose owner may no longer be active on the site.
