Beautiful Diana and Karen. Great edges!
I have done a bit more looking and haven't come up with anything to beat Here Lies Butch, but here are a few more with edges.
First year blooms on these:
Northern Spendor - this one performed beautifully its first year, perfect blooms that opened well even on the coolest of days
Annette's Magic - not particularly toothy its first summer, but so pretty.
Classic Rose - a gift plant, but it seems to be a nice one
In Your Dreams - one I have had for a long time, and it is always a pretty bloom
Snowflake Empress - A lovely white with a slight pink blush. Another one that always looks perfect here
Savannah Royalty - Another newbie to the garden, but it did well its first year
Lastly, another photo of American Freedom, another first year plant