I wonder about asking for this next feature. I would be desirable in some ways, but it might tend to turn some people off or seem like circumventing the "early dib gets the seed" principle.
Often we post wish lists before a swap so that A might notice that B really wants a specific seed variety X.
Then A decides to dig deep, find and give away a packet A was originally planning to hold on to.
Maybe A really wants to treat B for some reason.
However, A knows that if she just posts that seed variety in the general tradelist, someone else is more likely to get it than B.
For me, I might well want to give away my last packet of X to B, but I would not just throw it into the free-for-all.
The feature I'm dubious about requesting is a way to "pre-dedicate" a certain packet to a certain person. Maybe they would still have to spend a ticket on it, but that doesn't matter. I was hoping for a way to be sure that B will get X, if I go dig deep for X and put my last packet of it into the swap.
The upside is that it would motivate more people to donate seeds they might otherwise have held on to. It would let the donor feel that they had specifically given the seeds to the person they wanted to.
The downside that I'm aware of is that there may be people focused on "fairness", thought of as "everyone in the swap has an equal chance at getting any given thing". And it might create a feeling of "insider trading that I was excluded from".
Right now, I think that when A wants to give X to B, A just slips that packet of X into her "TO B" baggie without ever mentioning it in the swap list. In effect, just saving on postage.
I don't know if anyone objects to that kind of "just slip it in" process.
But if someone does object, now or in the future, especially the host of a swap, I'd like there to be some way to take advantage of the great "postage-efficiency" of a group seed swap plus the value of specific up-to-date wish lists, plus individuals' willingness to give some treasured seed to another person one-on-one, plus the fact that everyone has friends they would go an extra mile for.
Another downside I could imagine by stretching would be someone sending SO MANY one-on-one seeds that they started forcing the host to use bigger mailers on the return leg. Then again, the flat rate envelopes can hold a huge amount.
So maybe the existing practice is best, of slipping a "dedicated" seed packet into someone's baggie without ever putting it into the swaplist.