I got it repotted in an old Italian terra cotta. I had to take off more leaves than I anticipated but it had pretty healthy roots. They were just soaked with water.
I placed it off-center on purpose so that I would have enough room to water it.
In both pictures I put Echeveria minima beside it to show the difference because it is also in bloom.
It's not supposed to rain for the next few days and it was outside when I bought it so I'm going to leave it outside to dry out then move it under plastic when there's a chance of rain.